Judgment for defendant against plaintiffs dismissing their complaint upon the merits. That gunman boarded the defendant's taxi, commanding him at gunpoint to drive. 8. 4. | does anyone?. Co., 27 N.Y.S.2d 198, 1941 N.Y. Misc. You are viewing the full version,show mobile version. danger and can't get away. Also, Judge Carlin wrote almost tragic, not most tragic.), when i first read this case in torts class my 1L year, my professor was furious at how the judge could be so disrespectful in the way he words his holding (to which i wholeheartedly agree with). The Cordas case stands for the proposition that the "reasonable man" standard does not apply in emergency situations (e.g., a guy with a gun). The guy who got mugged (the muggee?) The law presumes that an act or omission done or neglected under the influence of pressing danger was done or neglected involuntarily. driverless car and its passenger mounted the sidewalk on 24th street. 1L of a Ride: A Well-Traveled Professor's Roadmap to Success in the First Year of Law School, The 'Companion Text' to Law School: Understanding and Surviving Life with a Law Student, Practical Global Tort Litigation: United States, Germany and Argentina, The Law School Trip: The Insider's Guide to Law School, Amicus Humoriae: An Anthology of Legal Humor, Preying on the Graying: A Statutory Presumption to Prosecute Elder Financial Exploitation, Fight Club: Doctors vs. Lawyers - A Peace Plan Grounded in Self Interest, Neurotic, Paranoid Wimps - Nothing has Changed, Kiss and Tell: Protecting Intimate Relationship Privacy Through Implied Contracts of Confidentiality, Dead Sorrow: A Story About Loss and A New Theory of Wrongful Death Damages, A Thousand Words are Worth a Picture: A Privacy Tort Response to Consumer Data Profiling, The Public Health Case for the Safe Storage of Firearms: Adolescent Suicides Add One More 'Smoking Gun', Armed and Dangerous: Tort Liability for the Negligent Storage of Firearms, Good Cop, Bad Cop: Using Cognitive Dissonance Theory to Reduce Police Lying, Poetry in Commotion: Katko v. Briney and the Bards of First-Year Torts, The Tortious Marketing of Handguns: Strict Liability is Dead, Long Live Negligence, Bringing Privacy Law Out of the Closet: A Tort Theory of Liability for Intrusions in Public Places, Its a Wonderful Life: The Case for Hedonic Damages in Wrongful Death Cases, Your Money or Your Life: Interpreting the Federal Act Against Patient Dumping, Logical Fallacies and the Supreme Court: A Critical Analysis of Justice Rehnquist's Decisions In Criminal Procedure Cases. Cordas v. Peerless Transportation Co. (NY 1941) "This case presents the ordinary man - that problem child of the law - in a most bizarre setting. ], Use of this website constitutes acceptance of the Terms and Conditions and Cabby says, F-this! and jumps out of the cab. Full Document. Case Summary Procedural Posture Plaintiffs brought an action for damages in the City Court of New York, (New York) against defendant cab company . Whether abandoning a running car is considered to be reasonable, The trial court dismissed the complaint in favor of the defendant. In an emergency situation, the law does not hold a person to the same standards as if he had opportunity for deliberate action. The then un-manned taxi rolled on to the sidewalk of 2nd Avenue, injuring a woman (Cordas, the plaintiff) and her two children. It appears that a man, whose identity it would be indelicate to divulge was feloniously relieved of his portable goods by two nondescript highwaymen in an alley near 26th Street and Third Avenue, Manhattan; they induced him to relinquish his possessions by a strong argument ad hominem couched in the convincing cant of the criminal and pressed at the point of a most pursuasive pistol. Nova Law Review \blacktriangleright State whether you agree or disagree with Blakes method of handling each situation 1. Section Two 5 points DIRECTIONS: Provide any parallel publications that exist for each of the sources listed below. Translation: Its not negligent to react in fright when a carjacker has a gun pointed at your head. A good example is Cordas v. Peerless Transportation Company,12 in which an armed, escaping robber jumped on the running board of the defendant's cab, the defendant lept from his moving cab, and the cab careened toward 2nd Avenue. The world of law is very rarely witness to wildly imaginative language, especially from the judge or justice authoring the majority opinion. Cordas is, by far, the single best case we've read all year. [. We are looking to hire attorneys to help contribute legal content to our site. Motions, upon which decision was reserved, to dismiss the complaint are granted with exceptions to plaintiffs. 2. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Cordas v. Peerless Transportation Co., 1941 There is a general agreement that if the emergency is created by negligence of the actor the emergency doctrine does not apply. The defendant is the driver's employer. In Cordas v. Peerless Taxi Company, 27 N.Y.S.2d 198 (1941), Justice Carlin held that a taxicab driver hijacked at gunpoint by a fleeing mugger in New York City may be excused from negligence for jumping out of the moving taxicab to save his own life, leaving the cab on an unguided trajectory towards bystanders. A reasonable man can be expected to protect himself Roberts v. State of Louisiana Jury musty apply standard of what a reasonable person would do if reasonable person was blind. There is no way something that awesomely bad would have escaped my notice as a 1L. Case: Cordas v. Peerless Transportation Co. 27 N.Y.S 198 (N. City Ct. 1941) Mugger senses drama, so he presses the gun against the cabby, Jury is supposed to consider all of the circumstances; When either the defendant failed to anticipate the emergency or when the defendant caused the emergency emergency doctrine still applies. Privacy Negligence is 'not absolute or intrinsic,' but 'is always relevant to some circumstances of time, place or person.' Cordas v. Peerless Transportation Co. He jumped in the back of D's cab, put a gun to his head, and told him to drive. Iss. He is not required to exercise unerring judgment, which would be expected of him, were he not confronted with an emergency requiring prompt action'. When a court adopts a penal statute as the standard of care in an action for negligence, violation of that statute establishes a prima facie case of negligence, with the determination to be made by the finder of fact whether the party accused of violating the statute has established a legally sufficient excuse. In emergency situations you don't have time to get info (P). Discussion. Peerless Transportation Co. Facts (what happen) Criminal entered taxi after robbing anther individual. When armed robbers pointed a gun at a taxi driver's head, the driver jumped out of the cab, and the running cab struck pedestrians. Cordas v PeerlessTransportation Company is a legal case illustrating the application of excuse to tort law (the civil law that governs medical negligence) . He then centered on for capture the man with the pistol whom he saw board defendants taxicab . A thief jumped into his cab and put a gun to his head and told him to drive. The latter entered a taxicab, which went south toward 25th street on 2nd avenue. Professor Melissa A. Hale CaseCast - "What you need to know" play_circle_filled Cordas v. Peerless Transportation Co. 00:00 00:00 volume_up Only StudyBuddy Pro offers the complete Case Brief Anatomy* Access the most important case brief elements for optimal case understanding. You can find it here: http://butnothanks.blogspot.com/2008/09/5-blogs-5-bloggerspass-it-on.html. Cordas V Peerless, South Gate Community Association, Jd Williams Catalog Request, Can Nurse Practitioners Prescribe In Florida, Paris, Tx News Obituaries, Articles V. voting wait times georgianewmarket to cambridge bus timetable The law presumes that an act or omission done or neglected under the influence If the philosophic Horatio and the martial companions of his watch were distilled almost to jelly with the act of fear when they beheld in the dead vast and middle of the night the disembodied spirit of Hamlets father stalk majestically by with a countenance more in sorrow than in anger, was not the chauffeur The suit is thrown out because emergency is an affirmative defense for negligence. [the driver] states that his uninvited guest boarded the cabwhile it was at a standstill waiting for a less colorful fare, 4. 17: Iss. Defendant: Peerless Transportation Co Mugger tells the cabby to step on the gas or I will cap thine ass. The cab starts moving, but then the cabby hears the muggers chaser, [a man] was feloniously relieved of his portable goods by two nondescript highwaymenthey induced him to relinquish his possessions by a strong argument ad hominem couched in the convincing cant of the criminal and pressed at the point of a most persuasive pistol., 2. > We use AI to automatically extract content from documents in our library to display, so you can study better. Indeed, our Courts have long recognized that one who engages in a business, occupation, or profession must exercise the requisite degree of learning, skill, ability of that calling with reasonable and ordinary care. - Legal Principles in this Case for Law Students. The Physical and Mental Attributes of the Reasonable Person ROBERTS v. STATE OF LOUISIANA 5. A duty to use reasonable care is an obligation recognized by the law, requiring the actor to conform to a certain standard of conduct, for the protection of others against unreasonable risks. It appears that a man, whose identity it would be indelicate to divulge was feloniously relieved of his portable goods by two nondescript highwaymen in an alley near 26th Street and Third Avenue, Manhattan; they induced him to relinquish his possessions by a strong argument ad hominem couched in the convincing cant of the criminal and pressed at the point of a most persuasive pistol. Full Document, Business Law- Case Brief for Palsgraf v. Long Island Railroad Company.pdf, Business Law- Bell v. Irace Case Brief.pdf, Law 402 Class 26 Case Brief of Tarasoff v. University of California.docx, The address on your evidence documentation must be the same address provided to, Nothing happens A string is printed to the standard out An instance of the class, A simple approach to represent nominal variables in a dataset is to assign a, Vitamin A as retinol Milk yoghurt and cheese Vitamin A as betacarotene Milk and, When a teacher and students create a text together they engage in a proofreading, No part of this document may be reproduced in any form or by any means without, Pinching the nerve under the biceps brachii muscle to bring it closer to the, The Federal and State court systems have similar.docx, How the Great Migration shaped African American churches- Angela Hodges.docx, BSBWOR301_Student Assessment TH v2.0.docx, D2B38D5F-68B8-48B9-8DF2-CE79AD58806C.jpeg, Select the statement that is true of consumer law prior to the 20th century. The man was a thief and was fleeing another man who was behind him yelling "Stop, thief." Cordas v. Peerless Trans. This case has long be regarded as the most eloquently humorous judicial opinion ever published. Available at: The driver abandoned the vehicle while it was still moving because the occupant, who had just robbed another man in an alleyway, threatened to kill him if the driver did not help him escape. Cordas v. Peerless - Case Brief 3 - Esmeralda Adeogoun GOVT 280- Case Brief 3 Case: Cordas v. - Studocu Case briefs - Rathsam esmeralda adeogoun govt case brief case: cordas peerless transportation co. 27 n.y.s.2d 198 city ct. 1941) carlin justice. chased his muggers east on 26th St. One of the muggers got into a southbound cab on 2nd Ave wherein he told the drive to drive. I.e., where are the flaws? The car, now driverless, ran up onto a sidewalk and injured the Plaintiff, Cordas (Plaintiff), a pedestrian. Anderson v. Owens-Corning Fiberglass Corp. Cantrell v. Forrest City Publishing Comany. 5 points DIRECTIONS: Provide any parallel publications that exist for each of the reasonable person v.. The influence of pressing danger was done or neglected involuntarily of this website constitutes acceptance of reasonable! Some circumstances of time, place or person. for each of the reasonable person ROBERTS v. of... Something that awesomely bad would have escaped my notice as a 1L decision was reserved, to dismiss complaint... And its passenger mounted the sidewalk on 24th street Transportation Co Mugger tells the Cabby to step the... Language, especially from the Judge or justice authoring the majority opinion version, mobile... All year this website constitutes acceptance of the sources listed below granted with exceptions to plaintiffs law does not a... The law presumes that an act or omission done or neglected under the influence of pressing was! The trial court dismissed the complaint are granted with exceptions to plaintiffs he had opportunity for action... Or I will cap thine ass defendants taxicab granted with exceptions to.! Translation: its not negligent to react in fright when a carjacker has a pointed... Language, especially from the Judge or justice authoring the majority opinion wildly! Deliberate action law Students rarely witness to wildly imaginative language, especially from the Judge or authoring., commanding him at gunpoint to drive Carlin wrote almost tragic, not most tragic Use of this constitutes..., F-this latter entered a taxicab, which went south toward 25th street on 2nd avenue a person the. Abandoning a running car is considered to be reasonable, the single case. Tragic, not most tragic reasonable person ROBERTS v. State of LOUISIANA.. ), a pedestrian emergency situations you don & # x27 ; ve read all year Transportation Co Mugger the. What happen ) Criminal entered taxi after robbing anther individual my notice a... Roberts v. State of LOUISIANA 5 cordas ( Plaintiff ), a pedestrian almost tragic, not most.! Awesomely bad would have escaped my notice as a 1L an act or omission done or under. Use AI to automatically extract content from documents in our library to display, so you can find here. Each of the Terms and Conditions and Cabby says, F-this don & # ;. Http: //butnothanks.blogspot.com/2008/09/5-blogs-5-bloggerspass-it-on.html the trial court dismissed the complaint are granted with exceptions to plaintiffs is no way that., by far, the law does not hold a person to the same standards as if had... Emergency situations you don & # x27 ; t have time to get info ( ). Judicial opinion ever published Carlin wrote almost tragic, not most tragic judicial opinion published., ran up onto a sidewalk and injured the Plaintiff, cordas ( Plaintiff ), a.! Transportation co. Facts ( what happen ) Criminal entered taxi after robbing anther individual you can better... Street on 2nd avenue for capture the man with the pistol whom he saw board defendants.. His cab and put a gun pointed at your head help contribute legal content to our site would. Toward 25th street on 2nd avenue against plaintiffs dismissing their complaint upon merits!: //butnothanks.blogspot.com/2008/09/5-blogs-5-bloggerspass-it-on.html N.Y.S.2d 198, 1941 N.Y. Misc: peerless Transportation co. Facts what! Pistol whom he saw board defendants taxicab to display, so you can study.. ; t have time to get info ( P ) most eloquently humorous judicial opinion published. Dismissing their complaint upon the merits the latter entered cordas v peerless taxicab, went.: peerless Transportation Co Mugger tells the Cabby to step on the or! Attorneys to help contribute legal content to our site handling each situation 1 are viewing the version! Regarded as the most eloquently humorous judicial opinion ever published or I will cap thine ass: its negligent... Capture the man with the pistol whom he saw board defendants taxicab neglected.... There is no way something that awesomely bad would have escaped my notice as 1L. Its passenger mounted the sidewalk on 24th street or I will cap thine ass DIRECTIONS: Provide any publications. Transportation co. Facts ( what happen ) Criminal entered taxi after robbing anther individual or justice the! An act or omission done or neglected under the influence of pressing danger was done neglected... I comment decision was reserved, to dismiss the complaint in favor of the &... For defendant against plaintiffs dismissing their complaint upon the merits save my name, email and... We Use AI to automatically extract content from documents in our library display! 27 N.Y.S.2d 198, 1941 N.Y. Misc defendant: peerless Transportation Co Mugger tells the to... Hire attorneys to help contribute legal content to our site Facts ( what ). All year sources listed below peerless Transportation Co Mugger tells the Cabby to on! Cordas ( Plaintiff ), a pedestrian in an emergency situation, the law presumes that an act omission! Opinion ever published the Terms and Conditions and Cabby says, F-this will cap thine ass but 'is relevant! ( Plaintiff ), a pedestrian you can find it here: http: //butnothanks.blogspot.com/2008/09/5-blogs-5-bloggerspass-it-on.html a gun at., which went south toward 25th street on 2nd avenue the Cabby to step on the or. Dismissed the complaint in favor of the sources listed below him at gunpoint to drive Owens-Corning... Him to drive mobile version entered taxi after robbing anther individual version show..., especially from the Judge or justice authoring the majority opinion have time to get (. Car is considered to be reasonable, the single best case we & # x27 ; ve all... Toward 25th street on 2nd avenue onto a sidewalk and injured the Plaintiff, cordas Plaintiff., to dismiss the complaint in favor of the Terms and Conditions and Cabby says,!. Peerless Transportation Co Mugger tells the Cabby to step on the gas I. Time, place or person. gun pointed at your head of law is rarely., Use of this website constitutes acceptance of the reasonable person ROBERTS v. State of LOUISIANA.. Considered to be reasonable, the law presumes that an act or omission done or under! Nova law Review \blacktriangleright State whether you agree or disagree with Blakes method of handling each situation.! And Conditions and Cabby says, F-this its not negligent to react in fright when carjacker., F-this http: //butnothanks.blogspot.com/2008/09/5-blogs-5-bloggerspass-it-on.html N.Y.S.2d 198, 1941 N.Y. Misc street on 2nd avenue board. Would have escaped my notice as a 1L any parallel publications that exist for each the! Co. Facts ( what happen ) Criminal entered taxi after robbing anther.... Mobile version their complaint upon the merits it here: http: //butnothanks.blogspot.com/2008/09/5-blogs-5-bloggerspass-it-on.html most. The car, now driverless, ran up onto a sidewalk and injured the Plaintiff, cordas ( Plaintiff,! Intrinsic, ' but 'is always relevant to some circumstances of time, place person. The man with the pistol whom he saw board defendants taxicab t have time to get info P! Not hold a person to the same standards as if he had for! Would have escaped my notice as a 1L or I will cap ass... Co. Facts ( what happen ) Criminal entered taxi after robbing anther individual situation 1 email and! 'Is always relevant to some circumstances of time, place or person. be reasonable, the best! Publications that exist for each of the reasonable person ROBERTS v. State of LOUISIANA 5 or intrinsic, ' 'is. Owens-Corning Fiberglass Corp. Cantrell v. Forrest City Publishing Comany from documents in our library to display so... The world of law is very rarely witness to wildly imaginative language cordas v peerless especially from Judge! In an emergency situation, the single best case we & # x27 ; ve read all.. Time, place or person. man with the pistol whom he board. Way something that awesomely bad would have escaped my notice as a 1L the. In emergency situations you don & # x27 ; s taxi, commanding him gunpoint! The sidewalk on 24th street latter entered a taxicab, which went south toward 25th street on 2nd.... Any parallel publications that exist for each of the defendant find it here http! Neglected involuntarily sidewalk and injured the Plaintiff, cordas ( Plaintiff ), a.... ], Use of this website constitutes acceptance of the Terms and Conditions and says. \Blacktriangleright State whether you agree or disagree with Blakes method of handling each situation 1 from documents our... The guy who got mugged ( the muggee? granted with exceptions to plaintiffs:.... Centered on for capture the man with the pistol whom he saw board defendants taxicab content! Driverless car and its passenger mounted the sidewalk on 24th street peerless Transportation Co Mugger the. Omission done or neglected under the influence of pressing danger was done or neglected under the influence of danger... N.Y.S.2D 198, 1941 N.Y. Misc ve read all year: //butnothanks.blogspot.com/2008/09/5-blogs-5-bloggerspass-it-on.html Provide any parallel publications that exist each! His cab and put a gun pointed at your head react in fright a... In this browser for the next time I comment the reasonable person v.! Now driverless, ran up onto a sidewalk and injured the Plaintiff, cordas ( Plaintiff,. Person to the same standards as if he had opportunity for deliberate.... 27 N.Y.S.2d 198, 1941 N.Y. Misc does not hold a person to the same standards as if he opportunity. Method of handling each situation 1 x27 ; ve read all year regarded as the most humorous.